Glock Vs Sig Vs 1911 Funny
LJ Bonham is a semi-subsistence hunter, hunting magazine editor, and firearms enthusiast who lives in the Rocky Mountains.
Gerald R. Ford Museum Wiki Commons
M1911 vs. Glock
The U.South. Ground forces changed the firearms world forever when information technology adopted John Browning's semi-automatic .45 caliber pistol in 1911. Gaston Glock inverse it yet again when he introduced his polymer-framed pistol in 1982, and ignited a argue which continues to this day. Which is improve?
The Legend
The M1911, and M1911A1, served the American war machine for 74 years until replaced with the Beretta M9. It is still used by various elite U.Due south. military and law enforcement units, and shows no sign it volition disappear from the market place someday soon—if ever. What made the 1911 a fable?
The 1911 proved more than reliable than other car-loading pistols in the early twentieth century. Mauser and Luger produced guns with very close tolerances to help accuracy, just grit and mud had nowhere to go in the mechanism—jams were frequent under agin conditions.
1911 And 1911A1 Compared. Note Grip Safety On Dorsum Strap And Thumb Rubber
Public Domain
Wiggle Room
John Browning built "wiggle room" into the 1911 on purpose. He reasoned a military sidearm didn't need match-grade accuracy; it merely had to finish an enemy at close range. He also knew military guns were used nether farthermost conditions: snow, rain, mud, grit, bitter cold, and high estrus. If the bullet never made it out the butt, the pistol became a liability.
1911 In "Condition One," Cocked And Locked
Michael E. Cumpston Creative Eatables
Browning'south Innovation
Previous pistol designs were complex and/or beefy. Browning created a sleek, simple weapon with two locking lugs machined into the barrel and corresponding slots in the slide. These locked the breech during firing and allowed a more than compact pistol with the barrel centerline lower to the grip which reduced muzzle flip under recoil. When fired, the barrel moved back with the slide a brusk distance and then a swinging link drew it down to mate with the cartridge feed ramp machined into the frame.
1911 Field Stripped. Notation Barrel Lugs And Swinging Link. Link Cross Pin/Slide Release Is In a higher place Barrel.
Public Domain
Swinging Link, Weak Link
While much simpler than previous designs, the swinging link did depend on ii pins that could wearable and neglect. The barrel-to-feed-ramp fit left a modest step the bullet olfactory organ had to traverse equally the cartridge entered the firing chamber, which proved a non-issue with total metal jacketed, round-nose bullets.
Faster Reloads
The 1911 used a seven-round, single-column, detachable magazine made from stamped sheet steel. Although information technology held ane more round than most revolvers, the magazine's lips were prone to damage if the magazine struck a hard object, which rendered information technology, and the pistol, useless. Despite this, the magazines enabled fast reloads for a higher rate of fire than other automatics or revolvers.
Compact Officer's Model 1911
Ca.Garcia.S. Creative Commons
A Place In History
All in all, the 1911 took a massive stride forward, and when combined with the hard-hitting .45 ACP cartridge, the gun proved its worth from Belleau Woods to Khe Sanh.
Modern Challenges for the Male monarch
As time progressed, the 1911 began to show its historic period. It struggled to reliably feed the hollow-betoken bullets which became common from the 1970s forrard—bullets John Browning could not have envisioned. The butt throat needed to fit tighter to the feed ramp so hollow points wouldn't catch as the slide shoved them from the mag into the chamber. A military machine specification 1911's loose, combat-friendly tolerances were of a sudden undesirable and an unabridged cottage industry sprang up with pistol smiths tightening and polishing 1911s to feed the latest ammo.
.45 ACP Cartridges: Military FMJ (Fifty), Hollow Indicate (R). The Hollow Signal's Blunt Nose Can Jam in a Stock 1911's Barrel Pharynx.
Public Domain
Curl to Continue
Read More From Skyaboveus
Enter the Glock
In 1980, Austrian engineer and industrialist Gaston Glock decided to enter the Austrian Army's competition for a new service pistol. Although neither he nor his visitor had ever built firearms, Glock wanted to utilise his skills with polymer technology to the problem.
Glock's First Pistol: G17 9mm
Ken Lunde Creative Commons
Channeling John Browning
Glock's engineers designed a new trigger mechanism, merely copied proven features from other pistols, such equally the integral camming wedge in John Browning'south concluding pistol design, the P-35 Howdy-Power. The wedge functioned similar the 1911's swinging link, just with fewer parts and tighter barrel-to-frame fit. The P-35 as well included a feed ramp machined into the butt throat. This solved the hollow point feeding issue.
The Glock Revolution
Glock adult a polymer frame for the new gun. A revolutionary design, this ultra-light frame would not rust. A shooter could grip it without gloves in sub-zip common cold or tropical estrus, and information technology flexed a small amount during firing which absorbed recoil.
The Austrian Army adopted Glock's pistol in 1982 and the earth took detect. Within twenty years, the Glock became the most widely used military and law enforcement pistol in the earth.
Combined with ferritic carburizing to protect the steel parts, a Glock is nearly impervious to corrosion and functions in the well-nigh farthermost conditions. It is so good, many special operations units utilise information technology, and the FBI adopted information technology in 2016.
Glock G36 Compact .45 ACP Pistol
Public Domain
Steam Historic period vs. Estimator Age
And then which is best, the tried and true, all-steel 1911, or the futuristic Glock? Allow's compare them surface area by expanse.
one. Structure
The Glock's frame is superior in about every way. It is rust proof, impact resistant, and lightweight, needs only modest lubrication, and fits both large and minor easily. Modern 1911's with stainless steel frames now rival the Glock in corrosion resistance. A steel frame's only theoretical advantage is it would not melt if exposed to burn down, although it would lose its heat treatment and become unsafe to use. The polymer frame enables a .45 caliber Glock 21SF loaded with thirteen rounds to counterbalance less than an unloaded, steel framed 1911.
The Glock'due south Polymer Frame Can Exist Molded In Special Colors. Note the Reinforced Polymer Magazine
Technococcus Creative Commons
2. Barrel Lock-Up
While Browning's swinging link and butt lugs improved over previous designs, the Glock is a step forward from in that location. The Glock's butt locks into the slide's ejection port which places it lower and closer to the hand than the 1911, a feature developed by SiG in the mid-1970s. Combined with the frame flex, the Glock has depression perceived recoil and less muzzle flip, which improves rapid-burn accuracy.
3. Feed Arrangement
Glock uses the Browning P-35's butt cam system. Combined with the feed ramp integrated into the butt's breach, the Glock is renowned for smoothen, reliable performance with hollow points.
Some modern 1911 clones have P-35-like feed ramps and besides handle hollow points reliably--an improvement over the original 1911.
Glock Field Stripped. Note Fewer And Simpler Parts; P-35 Style Under Barrel Cam And Barrel Feed Ramp
Public Domain
4. Trigger
Mil-spec Glocks and 1911's both have poor, 2-stage, military machine-style trigger pulls. The Glock has a spongy have-up followed by a firm, but not crisp, five-pound release. The 1911's trigger is creepy with an often heavy final release. Both guns were meant to resist a nervous soldier's itchy trigger finger. A competent gunsmith tin can better either gun'south trigger pull.
Premium 1911's from companies such as Kimber and Springfield Armory offer semi-custom production pistols with excellent triggers.
Even with re-piece of work, the Glock's trigger is not as precise as a well-tuned 1911, considering its trigger both cocks and releases the firing pin. The 1911's trigger simply releases the hammer so it has a short, single-action pull.
v. Safety
Both guns are very prophylactic if handled correctly.
The Glock'due south patented "Prophylactic Action™" has no external safeties. The gun will only fire when the trigger is pulled all the way to the rear—similar to a double-action revolver. If the shooter keeps their finger off the trigger, the gun will not fire. This is a distinct reward in a shootout since the operator doesn't need to remember to disconnect any safeties.
The original 1911 has two user-activated safeties. All Serial 80 1911'due south besides have a passive safety—the firing pin block plunger. To burn down any 1911, the shooter must become a firm grip on the pistol to depress the grip safety located on the frame's backstrap, and then ensure the thumb safety is in the downwardly, or "fire," position. This requires hands large plenty to manipulate both safeties.
Both pistols are designed and tested not to fire if dropped. The 1911 is safe either cocked or uncocked, per the U. Due south. Cavalry's requirement. The Glock meets, or exceeds, the Austrian Army'due south drib-examination protocols.
Every bit military service pistols, both the Glock and 1911 were intended for "condition three" comport (sleeping accommodation empty and activity decocked) since this is how most armies mandate troops carry a pistol. They are, still, safe in "condition 1" which is bedroom loaded and activeness cocked, if certain rules are observed.
The 1911'due south thumb prophylactic should exist engaged for status one carry, and the user must train to make prophylactic engagement/disengagement an instinctive activity. The Glock must be carried in a holster that covers the trigger guard to prevent annihilation from pressing confronting the trigger. Glocks should not be carried condition one in a waistband or any other method which does not shield the trigger.
Glock In Holster. Note Holster Covers Trigger Guard.
Public Domain
6. Accuracy and Reliability
The Glock and 1911 are accurate enough to accomplish their master mission: close-quarters battle. Tuned 1911's often take match-course accuracy, and Glock offers target models which rival whatever competitor'south product. Both can benefit from high-visibility afterwards-market sights.
An operator can cycle either gun'south slide ane-handed. All the same, this is non possible with whatsoever recoil spring guide rod equipped 1911, unless it has a special aftermarket rear sight.
Factory Glocks will feed any commercial ammunition except cast lead bullets. Mil-spec 1911s are just reliable with a round olfactory organ, and full metallic jacketed bullets. Only 1911s designed for hollow points are reliable with them.
The Bones 1911 Is Accurate Enough For Its Mission
Michael Due east. Cumpston Artistic Commons
vii. Ergonomics
The 1911 and the Glock have unlike grip angles. Which points better is a matter for each shooter to decide. Gen iv Glocks take adjustable grip panels, but they do not alter the basic grip angle. Glock controls are ambidextrous and manipulated with i hand. The basic 1911 is right-handed but, and small-statured users often need both hands to operate the gun. Lefties must either buy a purpose-built ambidextrous 1911, or modify a standard gun.
8. Combat Effectiveness
A .45 quotient 1911 holds 7 rounds in the magazine; viii with after-market mags. A Glock 17 chambered in 9x19mm holds seventeen in the mag. Glock offers replacement mags which hold up to thirty-three rounds. Their .45 ACP models concur upward to xiii.
Glock's ammunition chapters gives it considerable advantage in a fight. Glock'southward steel-reinforced polymer magazines are nearly indestructible, unlike sheet metal mags.
The Glock also field strips faster and easier, and has no minor parts that can get lost. Neither pistol requires special tools to field strip.
The FBI Adopted The Mid-Size Glock G19 in 2016
Vladimir Dudak Creative Commons
Closing Thoughts
The 1911 is a fable. It has performed well in every surroundings on Globe, but the design is over one hundred years old. John Browning fabricated some compromises, which he corrected in the P-35.
The Glock is a modern weapon made with aerospace quality materials and methods. Information technology is the nigh pop pistol in the world. Easy to shoot and maintain, information technology has proven itself in the nearly farthermost atmospheric condition.
Ultimately, whichever gun bests fits a person's shooting style and needs is the one they should apply. A well trained 1911 user is a formidable opponent, simply the gun requires diligence to master. Its crisp single-action trigger improves accuracy, and it fits shooters with the right sized easily well.
The Glock is best for people transitioning from double activeness revolvers. It is simpler to use than the 1911, and once the trigger is mastered, is simply every bit authentic in combat. Glocks can fire tens of thousands of rounds without malfunction or harm, and are more than corrosion-resistant than the 1911. It is likewise less expensive, on average, than the 1911, and fits small-statured shooters better.
The 1911 is a classic; the Glock is becoming ane. Two great pistols from two singled-out eras, and anyone is well armed with either.
This content is accurate and true to the best of the author'due south knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional.
© 2017 LJ Bonham
LJ Bonham (writer) on June 08, 2018:
John R. Wilsdon, cheers for the complement. I'm glad you enjoyed the piece. I assume you're referring to the belt-slide holster. I don't know what brand it is, simply most major holster makers offer like products. I'd suggest a quick spider web search for "belt-slide holsters." I'd start with DeSantis, Bianchi, and Galco.
John R Wilsdon from Superior, Arizona on June 03, 2018:
This is a very practiced hub. Thanks for all the info. Where can I become a holster like the leather 1 featuring the 1911 to a higher place?
Source: https://skyaboveus.com/hunting-shooting/Is-the-Glock-Better-Than-the-1911
0 Response to "Glock Vs Sig Vs 1911 Funny"
Post a Comment